Internet Society Analyzes Technical and Security Considerations in ‘Traceability’ Clause in India’s IT Rules 2021

Author picture

As the Delhi High Court starts hearing the writ petitions filed against the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 (IT Rules 2021), the Internet Society (ISOC) has released a comprehensive brief that analyzes the ‘traceability’ mandate contained in the IT Rules 2021, and its implications for digital security, businesses, people, and the national economy.

One of the most contentious aspects of the IT Rules 2021 is the requirement for significant social media intermediaries offering messaging services to implement traceability measures, compelling them to identify the first originator of messages, particularly on platforms utilizing end-to-end encryption (e2ee) like WhatsApp, Signal, and iMessage.

ISOC’s brief addresses several challenges associated with traceability. It discusses how proposed methods like the Kamakoti proposal, hashing, and metadata analysis could weaken encryption, affecting the security of e2ee. The brief also examines the impact on user privacy, especially for those relying on secure communications, and considers how traceability might conflict with privacy expectations in end-to-end encrypted environments.

Additionally, ISOC highlights potential security and technical challenges, including the handling of sensitive data and the feasibility of the proposed solutions. The brief further explores the legal and technical complexities of digital attribution, noting the difficulties in ensuring accurate identification while maintaining security and privacy.

The brief also considers how traceability could affect different user groups and businesses, particularly in sectors where secure communications are critical. ISOC emphasizes the importance of considering the broader impact on the digital economy and user trust in online services.

Neeti Biyani, Senior Advisor – Policy and Advocacy states, “India is witnessing rapid digitization and a significant expansion of its digital economy. In this context, people, businesses, and the administration need more security-not less. The traceability requirement in the IT Rules 2021 impacts security, confidentiality, cost, citizens’ rights, commercial trust, and investment-and may prove ineffective when deployed at scale. The government must lend its support to robust security standards.”

About Internet Society
Internet Society is a global charitable organization dedicated to promoting and protecting the open, globally connected, secure, and trustworthy Internet. Founded in 1992, ISOC has a network of over 120 chapters, special interest groups, and a global community of members committed to ensuring that the Internet is for everyone.

Recent Post

From India, For India: EVM Unveils Locally Storage Solutions Made in India Ram & SSD’s

Sebamed’s ‘Project Skin Deep’ Campaign Shows Proof of Real Beauty

Metrix to bring together Industry Leaders to Discuss Growth Opportunities of Rs 3.50 lakh Cr. Market for Home Products

Nurse Maria Victoria Juan from Philippines wins the Prestigious Aster Guardians Global Nursing Award 2024 worth INR 2 Crore

Lord’s Mark Industries Ltd. Strengthens Financial Governance with the Appointment of Sanjeev S Gupta & Associates as Peer Auditor

Green Ambitions Take Centre Stage as IVCA GreenReturns Summit 2024 Commences in New Delhi

TERI Hosts Global Research Leaders at the 6 th RD20 Conference: Accelerating Clean Energy Collaboration Among G20 Countries

Chambal Fertilisers and Chemicals Limited and TERI sign MoU for ‘Centre of Excellence for Advanced and Sustainable Agriculture Solutions’

LEAD Group Launches ‘Code.AI SuperTeachers Contest’ to Empower Educators and Nurture India’s Future Tech Innovators

Why Mannivakkam Near Vandalur Is Becoming a Homebuyer’s Haven: Real Estate Soars with Connectivity and IT Growth

L&T Finance Ltd. Celebrates 30 Years of Trusted Excellence

Education Minister Yogendra Upadhyay Hails Galgotias University at 12th International Conference on Library and Information Science

The Best Time to Start Retirement Planning is Now, says HDFC Life’s Latest Campaign

No More Winter Skin Woes, Thanks to Lakme Skincare

Shriram Finance Launches Inspiring Campaign #TogetherWeSoar with Legend Rahul Dravid

Ratul Puri Highlights Hindustan Power’s Efforts to Combat Water Scarcity in Uttar Pradesh

The Genes Way to Treat Yourself this Black Friday

Why Bengalureans Are Choosing Mysuru: A Real Estate Boom Driven by Connectivity and Quality of Life

Think360.ai Recognized Among Top GenAI Service Providers

Faridabad: A Thriving Hub Poised for Growth in NCR’s Real Estate Landscape

RDX Dance Championship Season 3 Grand Finale Concludes with Spectacular Performances

LPU Online Expands Program Offerings with Launch of Online BBA and M.Sc. Economics Programs

‘The Journey Home’: Celebrating Vedica’s Pure Himalayan Origin

India Women’s Leadership Conference 2024: Driving Gender Equality and Systemic Change Across Sectors

Parimatch Introduces Exclusive Markets Featuring Sunil Narine and Nicholas Pooran for the Abu Dhabi T10 League

“Abraj Omar”: An Elegant Haven Blending Sophistication and Spirituality in the Heart of Makkah

National Road Safety Mission for Kids Winter Edition Launch: Empowering India’s Future on Safer Roads

iPhone 16 Plus vs Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra: Which Flagship Phone Should You Buy

Discover the Best Mobile Phone Under 30000: OnePlus Nord 4

SPR India Launches Sky Tower 1, a Premium 45-Storey High-Rise Residential Tower in Perambur

Lotus Arts de Vivre Introduces Luxury Wedding Gifts for a Timeless Celebration

On Its 15th Anniversary, The Hans Foundation Launches Swasthya Cities Initiative to Transform Urban Ecosystems by 2030

100 Percent Plastic-free Husk Glasses Steal the Spotlight at Beverage Week Delhi 2024

NoBroker Hosts ‘Property Carnival’ in Chennai for Homebuyers

Salesforce Brings The First Edition of Agentforce World Tour To Delhi

Manthan School Ranked Among India’s Top 20 Schools in EWISR 2024-25

Raghu Vamsi Aerospace Group Lays Foundation Stone to Build New Facility in Hyderabad with the Investment of Rs.300 Crore

Ascendion Accelerates AI Innovation: New AI Studio Launched in Hyderabad

The Rise of Premium Luxury Residences: How NCR is Setting New Standards

Chandni Chowk Wedding Festival Draws 1.56 Million Visitors at Omaxe Chowk, Setting a Record Turnout

Vritilife Presents Brand Vision India 2030 Leadership Conclave – Empowering Leaders and Inspiring Change, an initiative by NexBrands Inc

Paisabazaar Launches Credit Card Reward Calculator to Help Consumers Maximize Reward Earning

Pat Cummins Teams up with Ruby to Invite Indian Cricket Fans to Come and Say G’day

Royalti Achieves an Unprecedented 200 Crores Sales at Oberoi Garden City Launch

La Pink Signs Parineeti Chopra as Its Brand Ambassador

MMTC-PAMP Honoured Among Elite 10 at Forbes India DGEMS 2024

Impact of AI on Employment: Future-Proofing Careers with Essential Skills

Massil Technologies Teams up with KrakenD as Value Added Reseller

Ekya Nava Inaugurated as India’s First K-12 School of Innovation, Creativity, and Design at Second Edition of FIND Festival

MediaTek Showcases Latest Smartphone, Automotive and IoT Innovations to Drive Digital Transformation in India

Vatika Group secures prestigious LEED Certifications Across Residential, Commercial, Retail, and Educational Projects

AirAsia Launches New Flight from Port Blair to Kuala Lumpur

Urban Pulse Innovations Pvt. Ltd. Launches Pick’n’Treat Mobile App to Tackle India’s Food Waste and Hunger Crisis

ITW Catalyst Refreshes itself to Catalyst 2.0

G Square: The Game Changer of the Real Estate Landscape in India

RHI Magnesita India Inaugurates its New Regional Corporate Office in Gurugram, Boosting its Presence and Driving Growth Across India, West Asia & Africa

Lava AGNI 3 Spurs 200% Growth, Achieves 3x Volume Surge Over AGNI 2 During Launch Week

Investing in Tomorrow’s Consumers: Understanding the MEGATRENDS driving Bajaj Finserv Consumption Fund

Hon’ble Minister Thiru. Anbil Mahesh Poyyamozhi Launches Avtar Group’s ‘Nipuni’, Career Readiness Program for Girl Students in Colleges

Parimatch Sports Brings Cricket to Life with 3D Billboard at Bangalore

Contributing Towards Digital India: PlayboxTV Launches Flagship Android Box to Digitalize Cable TV Boxes into Connected TV Experience

IFCCI Recognizes Impactful CSR Projects by Indo-French Companies at the 6th Annual CSR Conclave & Awards

Futuristic Cloud Data Centers: Bolstering India’s Digital Future

Phoenix Marketcity Pune Launches Wedding Festival: A Celebration of Special Bond, Elegance and Rewards

BriPublish Announces the 2024 Edition of the National Book Writing Fest (NBWF) for University Students: Free Participation for All

Padma Shri Kailash Kher Unveils Param Amrit, a Divine Skincare Brand

Presenting India’s Most Epic KFC in the Sky

Stop Hitting Children: Why Corporal Punishment Must End

adidas and Cult Come Together to Transform Strength Training and Promote Fitness in India

‘Your Happy Nest’ – TTK Good Home Launches Year Long, Pan India Campaign

2024 World Trade Centers Association (WTCA) Member Forum Advances Global Trade and Collaboration to Navigate the Ever-Changing Business Landscape

YES SECURITIES Launches Wize Whispers Quiz: A Fun-Filled Learning Experience

Pulse Candy Shines with Over 35 Awards in Less Than a Year!

India Ka Super OTT App, OTTplay Premium Partners with JioCinema

SKF Unveils Next-Generation Solutions at ISEA Tech and Innovation Summit, Driving Performance and Sustainability Goals

The Celebrity Hair Transplant Surge: A Confidence Boost for Stars and Athletes

Yellowstone International Film Festival Announces Stellar Lineup of Global Cinema for its 5th Edition

TUMI Celebrates the Joy of Coming Together for The Holidays

Research Meets Action: SGT University’s ASIA Institute Partners with AARDO to Combat Lead Poisoning Across Africa and Asia

Advaiya and Crayon Host Customer Roundtable to Explore Cloud Security and Modern Workplace Solutions

Tamil Nadu takes Centre Stage in World Travel Market London (WTM) 2024

Sunrise of Certified Real Estate Professionals: Lamrin Tech Skills University Awards Certification to the First Batch of ‘RESEED’

Joyville Shapoorji Housing Hosts an Electrifying Performance of Sukhwinder Singh Live Concert at SP Kingstown, Pune

Naad Ras Mahotsav: A Celebration of Faith, Devotion and Music in Honour of Shri Priya Priyatam Lal Ju

Shahi Exports Unveils New Brand Identity to Mark 50th Anniversary

Get in Touch

    By clicking “Submit”, I agree to Privacy Policy and Terms and Condition.